Showing posts with label Lockerbie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lockerbie. Show all posts

Permanent Second-toTop-Post / Start Point


(last real update 29 November 2010)

Welcome to “The Lockerbie Divide,” a site dedicated to addressing the mountainous divide in opinion that exists over Truth and Justice regarding the 1988 bombing of Pan Am 103. Some samples of the two sides can be glimpsed in a related essay, and it should be clear they are not equal in numbers or influence, nor in accuracy. One side wins on power, the other on Truth. Obviously I’m in the latter camp, but it’s more than just hyperbole at work.
The material on this site is all written by myself unless otherwise noted. My own posts vary from empty marked (incomplete) to major essays. Some is little more than "thinking out loud" and subject to change, but much else is actually at the cutting edge of what anyone knows about the case. 
The original plan for this site was to gather some of the amazing talent I'd encountered on the Internet into a powerful site for crossing and wearing down the divide. And I have gratefully accepted some amazing contributions from others:


> Dr. Jim Swire, leader of the British families of PA103 group - Comment on creation of the Lockerbie Divide
> Professor Robert Black QC, Lockerbie Trial "architect" - From Lockerbie to Zeist (via Tripoli, Tunis, and Cairo) (re-published from a book, on-line exclusive)
> Robert Forester, Justice For Megrahi campaign founding member - Circumstantial Jigsaw Puzzle, and also Justice for Megrahi Campaign (details about the group) 
> Barry Walker, inspired theorist -  Camp Zeist: Perils and Pitfalls of a Designer Trial
> Patrick Haseldine, former public servant - The South Africans Theory with rebuttals by myself and Robert Forrester 
And then, posts by others that weren't submitted, but taken by me, with generalized permission, from other sources.
>"Rolfe," JREF forum inspired researcher/commentator 
  - Some Background on Karol Sikora
  - Rewards and Bribery
These are now both among my most-viewed posts here. More excellence from Rolfe will  be coming up (with a head's-up next time).
> Various: Richard Marquise Disputes the Findings of the Zeist Court. Awesome comments from a post at The Lockerbie Case by Richard Marquise, Rolfe, Matt Berkley, Jo G, Ben Six, Ebol (the Bolliers), Full Inquiry, and myself. Subject: the FBI SCOTBOM chief's continued promotion of the evidence of "witness" Abdul Majid Giaka.
And finally, words by many people besides me skimmed from different sources, expressing doubts (or inverse certainty) about Megrahi's guilt. Recently updated, with 84 names, no Libyans or their lawyers, no known crackpots, just several QCs, lawyers, political and religious leaders, reputable journalists, academics, and experts speaking of their doubts. A varied list including Robert Baer, Noam Chomsky, David Frum, Margaret Thatcher (sort of), and Archbishop Desmond Tutu. 
> No one Seriously Doubts the Libyan's Guilt?
Also, learn about the Justice for Megrahi Campaign


How this site works: 
The post-dated blog format usually brings the newest post to the top, and I usually put the newest posts right beneath this. But I also reassign dates and times to bring certain articles near the top or further down. Simply scrolling the page may be confusing, especially if one is not familiar with the details of the case. The more useful organization starts here and progresses with links.

Comments and questions are encouraged wherever there's a "post a comment" type link. I offer heartfelt thanks to anyone who takes the time to read and engage this material. You’re probably here to learn something, whether you realize it or not, and I’d like to help.


The Sources
The information on this site draws from a variety of sources: official reports (PDF), books, magazine and Internet articles, opinions and commentary, digital videos, photographs, and most importantly Megrahi's second appeal paperwork (see link to the right, second from top) and the complete (?) transcripts of the 2000 trial at Camp Zeist. This is not openly available to most people, but I've been blessed with a full copy - over 10,000 inefficiently-formatted pages of people talking in great detail, for 87 days, about the evidence al Megrahi was convicted on. It's proven very useful so far in clarifying details, and will continue to offer gems to those who follow this site. Many of my sources, aside from the trial transcripts, will be gathered at the post Lockerbie Documents.


More Bite-sized
Guided tour of the case against Megrahi if you feel you're ready to look at the actual evidence. 

- Images and introductions to 12 key points of the case can be found in my Lockerbie cards collection. 
- And for those willing to learn but not in the mood to read, there's a page that links to numerous videos on the subject. 


Anyone intrigued or infuriated or otherwise willing to give me a piece of your mind, I'm willing to accept. I can be reached by e-mail at
caustic_logic@yahoo.com


- Adam Larson aka Caustic Logic
Spokane, WA, USA

"But Flight 103 was Behind Schedule..."

December 31 2010
lat edits Jan 3 2011

Note throughout: This post, text and graphics, are imprecise and not fleshed out with detailed research. The concepts are general enough, however, that this is acceptable. Do see beneath comments from Rolfe, who has looked at this better and offers more in a few long submissions.
---

"But Flight 103 was Behind Schedule" is one of the most persistent myths of the Lockerbie bombing. It's the standard answer when anyone asks why the Libyans set their timer so early. For example, the BBC Conspiracy Files episode on the bombing (2008) starts out:
In the end, it came down, as most things do, to a simple twist of fate. 600 seconds. That's all that was in it. Had the bomb which destroyed the Pan Am exploded just ten minutes later, the plane would have been over open water, and all the evidence most likely lost at the bottom of the sea. But as it was, the bomb blew up over land, and the small town of Lockerbie became a by-word for the worst act of terrorism ever to take place in Britain.
A montage of the effects is shown, and the next words, curiously, are: "the investigation turned on one tiny piece of evidence ... this fragment [shown, of an MST-13 timer] was the breakthrough that cracked the case." The time of explosion over land - 7:03 pm, just 38 minutes after takeoff - wasn't caused by "a simple twist of fate." It was a time set intentionally on a timer to achieve the goal of destroying the plane and, we've always been told, ditching the evidence at sea.

Of course the twist of fate in mind is the fabled delay in take-off that supposedly made the jet miss its date with anonymity. The  show specified ten minutes from the coast, suggesting a delay of at least that, if this interpretation is of any value.

First, if it is of any value, it isn't much. Consider the large span the plane was to take - crossing the entire Atlantic, on a northern great circle path from London to New York, something a bit like the image below. It was first to be vectored out over the northern length of Great Britain, a standard route for this flight (see below). After this long pass over Airstrip One,  there followed thousands of miles, several hours, of nothing but deep, icey ocean passing beneath. A host of minutes, aside from 7:03, were there to pick from between Novia Scotia and the original Scotland, ideally somewhere way out there between them.

Instead we learn the plane was ten minutes from the coast and the plotters had aimed for the coast. By the official story, they had an immense picture window of opportunity available, but they aimed only for just over the lower sill, and missed. It's a simple enough concept no picture is needed, but in case anyone wants to double-check the scale and how easy it is to hit that window, there it is. Put simply, green is smart, orange is stupid. Official story supporters clearly think nothing of the intelligence of the Libyans who they believe planned out the murder of so many Americans.

But was the plane behind schedule at all? Excerpt from the trial transcripts, speaking with air traffic controller Ronald Brown, Day 1, May 3 2000. [pp 154-158]
A [...] "1800" is the planned departure time of this flight.
Q What exactly does a planned departure time mean?
A The time at which an aircraft is expected to shut its doors and be ready for -- to make its
departure.
Q Now, I take it it's not the same time as the time that it actually takes off from the ground?
A It's not the same time as it would take off from the ground. It is the time that the aircraft is expected to shut its doors. It will then have to request start-up clearance. It will then have to start its engines. It will have to get taxi clearance and -- before it can possibly take off.

The plane then "departed" - pushed away from the gate - at 6:04, four minutes behind schedule. The feeder flight PanAm 103A was fairly late in arriving, and threatened to delay the whole operation. This flight was carrying about 1/4 of 103's passengers and luggage - including the bomb, we were told - but this was managed swiftly and flight 103 was only the slightest bit behind schedule at this point.

It did take 21 minutes then, including a second last-minute loading at a separate gate, before wheels up at 6:25. That may have been slightly longer than average, but not by much from my limited airport experience. It should easily have been foreseen by any sane plotter. But the Libyans aren't sane, we've been told, and must have simply confused departure with takeoff time, aside from presuming no delays. This must be what caused them to hit so far below the windowsil - a full 25 minutes in this case.

Otherwise, it's worth wondering if the blast timed to be over land really was a fluke. Did the plottes set it up that way? Maybe they wanted to be found? Nah, that sounds stupid. No wonder no one has argued that yet.

To establish the flight Path across the UK, I return to the conversation with ATC Brown:
Q And then A20 route?
A It was a low level airway from London Heathrow going through a reporting point called
Trent, which is TNT.
Q And then, "upper alfa 2 Pole Hill UB for [156] Margo direct Glasgow."
A That's the route that the aircraft would continue to take. After Trent, it would proceed via Upper Humber 2, via Pole Hill, upper Bravo 4 to Margo, flight direct from Margo to Glasgow, and then follows the upper air route 590 to 59 north and 10 west.
Q And then we see, "/ mach No. 0.84." What does that refer to?
A As it crosses the oceanic boundary and comes under oceanic control, the separation on
the ocean is made by reference to a mach number rather than a physical speed and knot.
And therefore the aircraft had planned to fly at mach decimal 84.
Q Mach being the speed of sound?
A Mach being the speed of sound.
Q And then "estimated elapsed times," what does that refer to?
A The estimated elapsed time in number 5 are -- it takes him one hour 24 minutes to get to
10 degrees west
. To 20 west is two hour nine minutes. To 30 west is two hour 47 minutes.
So it's cumulative times as it proceeds across the north Atlantic.
Q Thank you very much.

Some posters at the JREF forum helped me sort this out [link]. Something like a great circle-based fight path, still standard today, but from local weather problems arcing around Ireland, northeast across Great Britain to its rocky far corner. The flight plan passes roughly over Glasgow and, as "Rolfe" noted, nearly over the fabled Isle of Skye. This is my own rough graphic, tracing what others had found and noted. ATC Brown mentions the coordinates 59N and 10W. I fudged the path a bit north of the paths traced from, but it's still a bit south of the 59 line. So this is only approximately the spot to mark as a planned 84 minutes out.

But in general terms, we can see that Flight 103 would not be over even the loosest sense of ocean until approximately one hour after leaving ground - over 20 minutes later than it did, as opposed to the "600 seconds" cited by the Conspiracy Files.

Ocean would come sooner on a more southerly path, also standard. But 38 minutes out from expected take-off, marked here with a faint arc, is only over southern Scotland or Northern Ireland, depending. The orange smudge would be at least partly over land no matter the exact route, set for 7:03 like that.

And further, one would be a fool to just pinpoint the coastline. Clearly deep water is preferable to shallow coastal waters for hiding evidence, but more importantly, one should think in three dimensions and consider what six miles of elevation and air movement within it can do. Prevailing inland winds and early scatter of some bomb debris, giving the farthest spread to some of the best clues, could be foreseen. What happened over a small patch near Lockerbie left a trail of evidence extending tens of miles east clear across Scotland into northern England and to the North Sea (orange in image). Ironically, the only evidence delivered to Neptune would have been on the other side of the land. One would want to clear the last shore by at least that width to keep everything over the ocean.

As we started out, there is no reason not to aim for somewhere closer to above the mid-Atlantic ridge. But if one is impatient and needs the bomb to blow right after passing through three airports undetected, around the edge of the map is about the earliest point one should have aimed for. Even that is hoping for only slight delays, but considering effectively none, they undershot by a good 30 minutes at least. Stupid Libyans.

Stupider than you can know, we've been told in different words and even in "forensic science." They were using one of the most exclusive timers ever to fail with, a unit that pointed right to them and had blabbermouth Bollier fused into the story.  A 1/2" miracle  fragment of the MST-13 survived and fell on land, just as programmed. And they used a radio for their anonymous hidden bomb that, among all models on earth, was perhaps the only one to be associated mostly with the Libyan market. Several fragments of casing, circuit board, and the paper manual cover survived and fell on land. And the brown suitcase that witness Giaka saw the accused with the day before the bombing held all this together along with the clothes that Megrahi bought on December 7, brand new at a small shop that doesn't usually cater to Arabs. He did this at and past closing time, to maximize the memorability of his 6-foot-seeming frame looming over the Maltese man, together hallucinating rainfall in the shadow of confusing Christmas lights.

And they put this all, with the umbrella, into one spotted package, and opted to just drop it all on Scotland at 7:03. Or so we were told.

Or, for those who aren't aware of what this early 38-minute detonation means, vis-a-vis a more rational explanation, see the post Thirty-Eight Minutes. The time was selected by a combination of crude devices, designed of necessity, and relying on the friggin' Semtex-H blast to destroy all clues. This most likely did happen, prior to other clues (see above) replacing them well after the fact.

Guided Climb for Wary Novices

First posted Jan 16 2010
by Caustic Logic
last updates May 12


Left, convicted Lockerbie bomber, right, Col. Gaddafi's son 
and likely successor. The angrier this picture makes you, 
the more you need to read on.  Seriously.
--- 

In this article I reach out to those just learning about the controversy over Abdelbaset al Megrahi's guilt for the Pan Am 103 bombing. In particular, I'm speaking to my fellow Americans and worldwide the many "official story supporters." If you feel, since almost everything you’ve heard about the bombing from the government, from the news, from the people you talk with, has been based on the fact that Libyan agent Abdelbaset al Megrahi is guilty, this page is for you.

If your stomach was turned by "the bomber's" release to die (or plot?) at home, this page is for you. Steamed as hell about the "hero's welcome" afforded the convict? Did you boycott Scotch whiskey for a week in August?

Do you care whether or not these presumptions are actually true? Then this page is definitely for you. 
If you feel the true perpetrators of an airliner bombing that killed 270 souls should be known and punished - or at least known - this page is for you. If however you have no stomach to learn, or consider, or care at all one way or the other, this site is NOT for you.

If you're not sure, here are some sample thoughts: Frequently Un-Asked Questions and common retorts addressed.

A bit rusty on what Lockerbie/Flight 103 even means? Read The Magnitude and Firstness of the Lockerbie Bombing

And if you're somewhat curious but all this text is intimidating, you might be asking "isn't there a video version? A Youtube introduction?" Yes! Several of them! Watch a few and then if you care to, dig deeper into the facts and issues they touch on. That's part of how I got started figuring this stuff out.

But He's Guilty!
The byline after Megrahi's name, "Lockerbie bomber," is so widespread as to seem, to most Americans at least, a Natural Fact. British police, American investigators, the UN Security Council sort of, and three Scottish judges (or eight, depending on your take) all act in apparent belief in Libyan guilt via the case against the two accused. Heck, the Libyans themselves admit it (or so it's been made to seem) and paid up big cash. But ultimately words is words and deeds is deeds. Somewhere between the two and sometimes connecting them are the devious twins intelligence and evidence.

The FBI’s lead Pan Am 103 Lockerbie investigator, Richard Marquise, loves to differentiate the two, selectively. Marquise has often spoken up for the investigation he led, as being led by the evidence, not by politics. Mr. Marquise is occasionally active discussing the issue in e-mails with compatriots and in the pitched comments section of an amazing blog run by Professor Robert Black. In one recent message he reiterated to commenter (and something of a mentor to me) “Rolfe”
"There is no reason whatsoever for anyone to believe me. I (and my colleagues on both sides of the Atlantic) collected the evidence and presented it to a Scottish court. It was they--not me--who found the evidence compelling enough to convict Mr. Megrahi. It was they who believed the evidence was proof beyond a reasonable doubt and they are the only ones who needed convincing." [emph added]
But the judges aren't all that mattered, or else they wouldn't have needed that evidence brought in, by investigators they trusted and believed. Beyond that we have seen sternly worded government press releases and talking head opinions and Senatorial posturing as tough on Libya, and the expectant media coverage of the trial and "disastrous" release and Megrah's continuing refusal to die. Public opinion matters, which is probably why Mr. Marquise still takes enough interest to write books, grant video interviews, and debate the issue on blogs.

There’s no doubt, as the man says, "Convicted Lockerbie Bomber" Megrahi is legally guilty of the conspiracy he was convicted for in a Court of Law back in 2001. Three separate judges specially appointed to preside without a jury unanimously decided, on January 31 2001, that al Megrahi was guilty of the scenario related at trial. It’s got the binding power of law. Nations have moved by the decision.

Yet in the real physical world he and we inhabit, in which a certain plane with 259 then-passengers ruptured at a certain altitude... well, that's another story that the masses haven't heard yet.

How can there be any doubt, when the whole point of a trial is to remove doubt within reasonable reach, and bring legal authority in line with established reality? Consider that the judges, in the unusual trial at Camp Zeist, also unanimously decided Megrahi’s accomplice was NOT guilty. Both decisions have got the binding power of law, so legally (it could be argued) Megrahi did it without an accomplice, which is physically all but impossible. That’s the difference.

Also consider that O.J. Simpson was acquitted, and that millions of Americans have no problem questioning a high-profile judgment there.

Some of the most important details of how the trial was run, what the judges considered and how, prosecution and defense strategies, and the like, is beyond the faculties of the current staff of this site. We will try to locate the best analyses from the legal perspective in the near future, but even then and especially now, the site will focus mainly on the evidence the case was built up on.

Marquise admitted to Time magazine in 2007 the case was “based on "a series of circumstances," and all must be true for Megrahi to be guilty.” Unfortunately, each piece, on close examination, is either inconclusive, unverified, implausible, handled strangely, has changed over time, is associated with million-dollar payments, presents logic problems on a variety of levels, or some combination of the same. There is indeed serious reason to suspect the judges got it wrong, right at square one, by accepting the prosecution’s evidence at all. This may sound like an extreme position, but some brilliant and well-informed people out there agree and are convinced that at least one, or two, or all of the central planks are unacceptably suspect. As this site will demonstrate, such attitudes are fully justified.

Introductory-level, point-by-point Guided tour of the case against Megrahi, including the stuff you haven’t been told yet. Just what’s Wrong with the "official story"?

So Then, Who Did Do It?
This is not your standard conspiracy theorist fantasy, These are often based on a few small problems with the "official story," a feeling that something "isn't quite right," selectively read evidence and a slew of bad presumptions, stated with born-again fervor. There are those who will cloud the issue and make it all seem wildly speculative, but in fact, the most likely "alternate" scenario is not the slightest bit outlandish, in itself. In fact, many revisionists lead with their answer to this stumper it's so clear.

If Libyans didn't run this sow, then the "next best" evidence points not to the CIA or reptoid alien overlords, but to a violent Palestinian group based from Syria, and acting on behalf of the Ayatollahs in Iran. Iran had motive - the US shoot-down of Iran Air 655 with 290 aboard. They had the means - money and connections leveraged into a deal with the PFLP-GC who set up a bomb-making operation in Germany. The opportunity - well, airports can be breached when there's a strong will.

The original section on this was too long for an intro article and has been removed to the post Whodunnit and Howitdun.

Proponents of the PFLP-CG theory, or any other alternate story, have less of the facts established for them by the investigation and must rely on speculation and less trustworthy lower-tier "intelligence." And we've spent most of the time between the bombing and now in a confusing stew of misinformation that has bogged down those who would question (essentially, the "drug swap theory"). But contrasting this and clarifying the PFLP-GC hand is the the London origin theory. From the obfuscated to the suppressed to the always-obvious, the evidence supporting a bomb introduction at Heathrow airport, London.

"Have I been lied to? Really? That Bad?"
We could, just for one example, consider star witness Giaka. He was all the rage in 1991, his elaborate tales (he majored in literature!) of Megrahi's and Fhima's guilt connected the less direct clues and so underpinned the indictments issued by a US grand jury and read out by US and UK Justice officials in November. And this decision underpinned the sanctions that cost economic distress and some number of lives in Libya over the 1990s, demanding only the two be handed over for trial in the US.

Tripoli tried to relent for years to a compromise trial, until one was established and the suspects handed over in 1999. Before the evidence brought before judges in 2000, the Scottish Crown's prosecutors called on Giaka again, with nine years to think it over, as what many called the "star witness." With the Defense's assistance, the Judges found Giaka to be what he's universally considered today - a charlatan for hire that the Americans pimped to support their flimsy case - the Scottish investigators, prosecutors, and so on accepted and promoted this; they didn't necessarily have to willfully conspire, but somehow, a cluster of lies had become a multi-corroborated legal reality by which nations could be punished and which still holds most peoples' minds.

Go ahead and read the indictment of Megrahi and Fhimah. Of 16 points (a-p), most of them (12) are inconclusive statements about the two's business deals and movements. Of the few conclusive points, (m)'s main thrust that on December 20 they "did ... cause a suitcase to be introduced at malta" is pure Giaka, and laughed out of court as clearly made up much later to appease the Americans and secure his and his family's relocation there. Point K on stolen tags might be from Giaka. I'm not sure about point (c) "...have in your possession and under your control quantities of high performance plastic explosive..." Giaka said Fhimah kept Megrahi's TNT, not plastics, in a locked desk drawer at the airport. I've never seen any other support for either of them touching any explosives, so where this came from is a mystery. He also gave other clues that didn't warrant direct mention here, like the report on bombing a "British plane" that Giaka himself was asked to write and hand in to Megrahi.

If obvious falsehoods like this that can get through for almost a decade, what else might still be legally accepted today despite being physically untrue?

The Magnitude And Firstness of the Lockerbie Bombing

Adam Larson/Caustic Logic
March 9 2010
last edit March 10 2am


This post is for those too young to remember or too unclear or numbed to understand or feel the significance of the bombing of Pan Am 103 and the geopolitical maneuvers following it. At 7:00 PM on December 21, 1988, the darkest day of the year, Pan Am flight 103 was just reaching cruising altitude nearly six miles above southern Scotland. The Boeing 747 was carrying 243 passengers and a crew of sixteen, mostly returning home for Christmas. 38 minutes after they had left from London’s Heathrow airport to New York’s JFK, at a hair before 7:03, a bomb detonated in the forward cargo hold and ruptured the hull. What followed can best be understood by viewing this amazing and probably quite accurate animation:

Prior to the 9/11 attacks in New York and Washington, the bombing of Pan Am 103 had stood as the deadliest ever terrorist attack on American civilians, and it still holds a distant second place. 270 people died in the attack, 189 of them Americans, including many military service members, college students, and young children. Eleven residents of Lockerbie, Scotland were killed when the main part of the plane plowed into the Sherwood Crescent neighborhood.

What followed the crash was “the largest mass murder trial in British history,” first covering the 800 sq. miles of debris and later the global mazes of a cross-border plot. [NYT] Naturally, the Scottish police backed by the American FBI and other US and UK agencies led the investigation.

The responsible airline, Pan American Airways, had been until the 1980s an American giant of aviation, the World Trade Center of the skies. After Lockerbie, they were vilified, bankrupted and destroyed by a string of lawsuits filed over their egregious security breaches at Frankfurt Airport. This doesn’t even count the still unacknowledged security breach at Heathrow that allowed the bomb to slip onto PA103 there.

The actual perpetrators were also pursued; “Lockerbie was perhaps the first truly global terrorism investigation.” [Time] This gave American and British authorities more people than usual to tell how things are. Germany, Malta, Jordan, Switzerland, and Sweden especially had significant roles in forming or following the investigation’s course. This had led to Libya with the joint Scots-American indictments of al Megrahi and Fhimah in November 1991.

After that the case moved to another level and witnessed, in 1992, the United Nations Security Council demanding the two accused be handed over for trial in the U.S. Sanctions were imposed when the demand was (inevitably) refused. “This is the first time the Security Council has ever demanded the extradition of citizens of one country to stand trial in another or implicitly accused a member government of involvement in terrorism.” [NYT] When the two accused were eventually handed over in 1999 for a compromise trial the Americans had prevented for years, obviously it was the first time such a demand was honored.

Alan Gerson was involved with pressing lawsuits against Libya for victims’ families, wrote a book with Jerry Adler (The Price of Terror, 2001) that explained a massive first - the unprecedented rulings and Congressional act establishing that a “rogue state” like Libya was exempt from the coverage of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, “a much bigger change than the families had ever sought, or perhaps needed.”
“Early on, Gerson and Zaid had intended merely to carve out the narrowest possible exception to the rule of sovereign immunity. […] they never sought to achieve a new world order based on the rule of law […] Instead the government got the FSIA amendment, which […] opened the doors for individuals to take on foreign governments for a much wider range of offenses, with consequences no one quite anticipated.” [p 295]
The way to suing foreign governments for alleged violence against Americans opened by these Lockerbie-led rulings has since been used in cases against Iran, Cuba, and other unloved nations, besides Libya.

The trial of Megrahi and Fhimah itself was held at “Kamp van Zeist” in “neutral” Netherlands. It was “the first time a patch of overseas soil has been designated Scottish to allow such an event.” [NYT] It was also perhaps the first time such a trial had been held in “a former NATO base to which the air force of the United States still had extant treaty rights of access.” [Robert Black]

Assorted firsts of the Lockerbie trial at Camp Zeist:
“… the first time a Scottish court has sat on foreign territory. Unusually, there was no jury.” [BBC]
“…the first Scottish murder trial to use judges instead of a jury. […] the first time a trial in what is nominally Britain has attracted the wide attention usually associated with the American courts." [NYT]
"'In many senses this trial is unique,' said John P. Grant, who leads a team of law professors from the University of Glasgow studying the trial and helping journalists understand Scottish law. 'It may become the longest trial in British history. It certainly will be the most expensive.'" [NYT]
“...the first time that LiveNote software has been used in a Scottish court to produce simultaneous transcripts; […] the most expensive and possibly the longest trial in Scottish legal history, employing the largest prosecution and investigation team without even including US Department of Justice personnel; […] held in what is quite possibly the most secure and most high-tech courthouse ever built." [Jurist]
The testimony of Libyan defector, CIA asset, FBI star witness, and obvious fabricator "Abdul Majid Giaka" was another first. As Gerson and Adler put it, “never before had the CIA permitted one of its intelligence sources to testify in open court about his work, and his testimony quickly showed why.” [p 282-83] The judges were forced to dismiss the tales that originally provided the skeleton of the case against Libya, while accepting the boneless mass that remained.

Following the guilty/not Guilty verdict of January 31 2001, Libya eventually negotiated a settlement with victims’ families – eventually settled in 2003 at $2.7 billion plus an admittedly hollow statement of “responsibility” for things Libyan agents actually do. Jim Kriendler of law firm Kriendler & Kriendler (New York), who represented some of the victim’s families (none too well says Gerson), called it “the first time that any of the states designated as sponsors of terrorism have offered compensation to families of terror victims." [UNWire] When Americans and the BBC use that agreement and mammoth settlement as evidence that the Libyans really did it, obviously that’s the first time such an original gesture was twisted in such a way.

In these and other ways, long before the controversial release and "Hero's welcome" granted to the "convicted bomber" in 2009, this Lockerbie attack and its long fallout are highly relevant and worthy of careful scrutiny. Considering the case underpinning all of the above is so full of questions, it becomes doubly so. It may stand nowhere near first among issues of global justice that demand action, but it's certainly one among many and a fascinating one at that.
---